Though they were far from fluent going forward, United put in a solid defensive showing to earn a point at Villa Park

Erik ten Hag's future at Manchester United remains unclear, but his side put in a spirited showing against Aston Villa on Sunday to earn a 0-0 draw against Unai Emery's in-form side.

Marcus Rashford had the first effort of the game as he cut inside and forced Emiliano Martinez into a save, and while Villa threatened through Morgan Rogers and Jaden Philogene, United looked relatively comfortable in defence.

Rashford again tested Martinez after the break while Andre Onana kept out a long-range effort from Youri Tielemans at the other end. Bruno Fernandes then went closest to breaking the deadlock when he hit the crossbar from a free-kick, but in the end, neither side could force a breakthrough and had to settle for a point each.

GOAL rates United's players from Villa Park…

Follow GOAL on WhatsApp! 🟢📱AFPGoalkeeper & Defence

Andre Onana (6/10):

Only really stretched on one occasion when he denied Tielemans from range. Otherwise was solid with his handling and his distribution.

Noussair Mazraoui (6/10):

Did OK defensively, even if his play in possession lacked much imagination. Off at half-time, presumably due to injury.

Harry Maguire (6/10):

Did a decent job up against Watkins, even if he did pick up a booking for a stray arm when forced into the channel. Injury meant he was forced off at half-time.

Jonny Evans (9/10):

Absolutely outstanding. Nothing got past the 36-year-old veteran as he threw his body into challenges and made countless blocks and clearances. Should remain in the team after this.

Diogo Dalot (7/10):

Had a tough task up against Bailey but did enough to keep the Jamaica international pretty quiet. Again drifted into midfield so United could outnumber Villa centrally before saving a certain goal when blocking Philogene's stoppage-time effort.

AdvertisementGetty Images SportMidfield

Christian Eriksen (5/10):

A third-minute booking suggested this was going to be a difficult day for the Dane, and he was a non-factor defensively thereafter. Did have a couple of nice touches in possession without ever looking like cutting Villa open.

Kobbie Mainoo (5/10):

Returned from injury but not the teenager's best showing. Booked in the first half, too.

Bruno Fernandes (4/10):

Gave the ball away constantly in the first half as he tried to be too clever as United attacked. Improved slightly after the break and struck the crossbar with a free-kick, but still not at his best.

Getty Images SportAttack

Alejandro Garnacho (5/10):

Struggled to get involved early on but gradually worked his way into the game and gave Digne a couple of problems. Lacked much cutting edge, which was summed up when he failed to put Fernandes in when clean through in stoppage-time.

Rasmus Hojlund (4/10):

Made a couple of decent runs in behind, but was otherwise a non-factor in the game as United struggled to find the No.9. Replaced by Zirkzee just past the hour-mark.

Marcus Rashford (7/10):

Enjoyed an excellent first half as he caused Cash all sorts of problems, and tested Martinez on a couple of occasions either side of the break. Lucky to avoid being sent off for two yellows before being replaced.

Getty Images SportSubs & Manager

Matthijs de Ligt (5/10):

On for the injured Maguire at half-time but still doesn't offer much confidence with his reading of the game.

Victor Lindelof (6/10):

Forced into action at right-back and did well in an unfamiliar role despite Villa looking to target his flank.

Joshua Zirkzee (4/10):

Given over 25 minutes to make an impact but failed to keep hold of the ball when he got it and never caused a threat.

Antony (6/10):

Had one effort saved by Martinez after coming on for Rashford.

Casemiro (N/A):

On inside the final 10 minutes for Mainoo.

Erik ten Hag (6/10):

Changing his centre-backs was a brave call but one he was rewarded for, especially by Evans. Still needs to find his best attacking combination, though.

Special Offer

Claim your exclusive bonus now! Click below to continue.